chez del - hat star wars iii gesehen
Montag, 25. August 2003
25. August 2003 um 12:25:57 MESZh

An Interview with Tin Maung Than

Tin Maung Than is a noted social critic who recently fled to Thailand after being accused of distributing transcripts of a speech by Brig-Gen Zaw Tun, a former deputy economic planning minister who attacked the Burmese regime's handling of the economy. The former editor of Thintbawa magazine, Tin Maung Than spoke to Irrawaddy correspondents Min Zin and Moe Gyo in Bangkok shortly after his arrival in Thailand. [...]

Can you tell us about your experiences dealing with censorship in Burma?

Tin Maung Than: In my career, sometimes I succeeded and other times I failed in dealing with censorship. By succeeding, I mean that I was able get past the censors and at the same time get my message across to my readers. But sometimes readers didn’t understand what I meant. Other times, I couldn’t cross the [censorship] line at all. So I would call theses cases my failures. It happened that way sometimes.

Dealing with the censor, you have to be very tactful. Sometimes we have to change the presentation style. From the Western point of view, some of our articles are too long. But we have to make them long because it is sometimes necessary to have some cover-up. There are always two messages, [one on] the surface and [another] underneath. When you read the article, you can find the surface message and then go to the underneath message.

In the past few years, there has been an explosion of journalism in Burma. Some say that the atmosphere for intellectual creativity has improved, but at the same time, you still have censorship. Do you see any kind of contradiction in these two trends?

Tin Maung Than: I think there is no change, specifically [with regard to] tolerance of dissenting views. But in my experience, the regime can tolerate it to a certain extent if we are talking about economic or development policy. But they would never tolerate any political discussion. Every time we get into that area, we get censored. In a way, [there has been some] improvement. But overall, I don’t think there is any real relaxation.

[...]

To what extent does the junta react to the international media? Who monitors the media?

Tin Maung Than: I think the international media has a very important role in influencing policy. For example, the government allowed a recent issue of Time magazine, in which they made a box on Aids in Burma, to enter the country. They tolerated the criticisms. I think that they consider [foreign news reports] when formulating policies. Not the top brass, but high-ranking officers who have to report to the generals. This link is very important. The high-ranking officers who are close to the decision-makers read every piece of work. And they have to acknowledge the international perception. You cannot get immediate results, but it has a long-range effect. But even high-ranking officers have limitations. They try to persuade their bosses to change policy, but the system is rigid.

What about the media’s analysis of splits in the leadership? What kind of impact does this have?

Tin Maung Than: Here you have a classic response. They will pretend that they are united. Maybe for six months or one year they will have unity. There is policy conflict between military supremacy and development. One group represents supremacy and the other development. This is why you have ceasefire agreements with minority groups--because one side is oriented towards development.

Can you be more specific? For example, how does this apply to the Maung Aye and Khin Nyunt factions?

Tin Maung Than: I won’t comment on people. When you focus on a person, at the same time you are restricted from their thinking. You are attached to that person and you focus on that person; this is what happens in politics. I would rather be detached from the person and focus more on the policies and ideas. I assume that apart from the Khin Nyunt faction there are [other moderate] groups. If you are limited to Khin Nyunt, then when Khin Nyunt is kicked out, you have no choice but to become more responsive to the hardliners. That is a very grave danger in our thinking. I would rather focus on the assumption that there are various moderate forces.

In every organization you have hardliners and moderate forces. Sometimes in democratic organizations you can see who is moderate and who is a hardliner. In authoritarian organizations, particularly rigid organizations like the military, you can’t easily see who is moderate and who is hardline. [People assume] that Khin Nyunt is moderate and Maung Aye is hardline. Don’t focus on the person. Let’s assume that we have moderate forces in the military and you have to adopt your strategy to deal with these forces.

full text

Online for 8280 days
Last update: 04.01.11, 09:56
status
und du? du bist nicht wirklich dabei.
this way
menu
... home
... topics
... galleries

... Antville.org home
recent updates
A few years ago, some music festivals seemed to reflect a world that was increasingly organized around obsessive fan Web sites. Like-minded listeners were forming micro-communities online, and you would...
A few years ago, some music festivals seemed to reflect a world that was increasingly organized around obsessive fan Web sites. Like-minded listeners were forming micro-communities online, and you would...
by del (18.05.05, 00:29)
Achtung!
. Wir weisen höflichst darauf hin, dass KEINE KAMERAS, FOTOAPPARATE, TONBAND- oder andere AUFZEICHNUNGSGERÄTE mit in den Kinosaal genommen werden dürfen. Auch die Mitnahme von MOBILTELEFONEN ist nicht gestattet. Diese müssen...
by del (08.05.05, 23:23)
phil neues 007
Ein Neuigkeitenbrief aus der Gumpendorferstraße. Diesmal erstmals mit zwei Veranstaltungen an einem Wochenende noch dazu extralangen: Sa., 23. April, 12 - 24 Uhr: OFFENE MARATHONDOMINOLESUNG UNEIGENER TEXTE Anlässlich der derzeit laufenden UNESCO-Weltdekade der Alphabetisierung...
by del (21.04.05, 13:21)
phil neues 006
. phil neues aus der Gumpendorferstraße - garantiert 100 % aprilscherzfrei. FRÜHSTÜCK! Es stehen folgende Menüs zur Wahl: Frühstückspensionsfrühstück feat. Melange, Schinken, Käse, Landei, Marmelade, Butter, zwei Semmeln um 6,8 Italienisches Frühstück feat. Cappuccino, Salami,...
by del (01.04.05, 11:36)
. heute die metallica-doku gekauft. in der metro.
. heute die metallica-doku gekauft. in der metro.
by del (09.03.05, 01:28)
. Bier statt stilles Wasser, Alltags-Texte statt hermetischer Lyrik - das kam auch bei Leuten an, die bei Buchhandlungs-Lesungen vor Langeweile vom Klappstuhl kippten. ... Plötzlich ging man nicht mehr "zu einer Lesung",...
. Bier statt stilles Wasser, Alltags-Texte statt hermetischer Lyrik - das kam auch bei Leuten an, die bei Buchhandlungs-Lesungen vor Langeweile vom Klappstuhl kippten. ... Plötzlich ging man nicht mehr "zu einer Lesung",...
by del (25.02.05, 23:28)
phil neues 005
. Bevor wir zu den philspezifischen Neuigkeiten kommen eine pressierende Mitteilung aus dem Möbeldepartment: bananasfiftiesmaskenball im espresso burggasse 59 > fr.25.feb (HEUTE!)> ab 19 uhr bartausgabe > freibierfass > begrüssungsschaumwein > live...
by del (25.02.05, 13:59)
. Farewell, Hunter S. Thompson.
. Farewell, Hunter S. Thompson.
by del (25.02.05, 13:58)
weblogs
search
 
calendar
November 2024
So.Mo.Di.Mi.Do.Fr.Sa.
12
3456789
10111213141516
17181920212223
24252627282930
Mai

RSS Feed

Made with Antville